POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

General questions or comments about either of the Port Orleans Resorts. Need to know something that's not covered by the rest of the site? Ask here!
Forum rules
Please check out the FAQs Page before posting, in case your question has already been answered.
rksteel
Posts: 2
Joined: July 28th, 2016, 8:19 am

POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

Unread post by rksteel »

Looks like we are heading back to Disney next year. The family loves staying at the POR and we have always stayed in the Alligator Bayou section. Now we are thinking about staying in Magnolia Bend, requesting either Acadian House or Magnolia Terrance (not interested in a royal guest room).

My question is, for those how have stayed in both sections, what do you like or dislike? Are you happy with either section or do you prefer one over the other?

Thank you in advance for your comments.
User avatar
Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 2094
Joined: September 11th, 2008, 6:44 am
Contact:

Re: POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

Unread post by Admin »

I like both to be honest, we switch around a bit. Either way, just make sure you're not too far out at the back section of the resort to keep the walking manageable. See the FAQs section for more info, http://www.portorleans.org/faqs.php#Choice . You won't get a fold-down bed in the mansions though.

Andre
Image
- The Unofficial Visitor's Guide to the Port Orleans Resorts in Orlando, Florida -
User avatar
MardiGroggy
Posts: 290
Joined: August 11th, 2013, 10:30 am
Location: North Florida

Re: POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

Unread post by MardiGroggy »

Here is my take on the subject. First of all, the room layouts are the same, except for the decor and the fold down bed. Same square footage, same bathrooms, sink area, etc. As Andre said, you only get the fold down bed in the AB rooms. The decor in the AB rooms is, as you know, woody/rustic, the Mansions are more "manor house." The outside grounds/landscaping in AB is woodsy/natural and the Mansions are more manicured garden-ish. The quiet pools in AB are curvy, free-form shaped, the Mansions are rectangular. There are three quiet pools in AB, two in Mansions. The AB buildings are in 2 story pods, without elevators, spread over a wider area. The Mansions are lined up in a row and have three floors, with elevators. You can end up farther away from the main building area in AB. Ol' Man Island is about as convenient to both. It really boils down to what sort of decor/surroundings you like, and how far you are willing to walk, if you get assigned to the 30-something buildings. Like Andre, we have stayed many times in both, and have never been disappointed in either, but we prefer the more rustic AB, as long as we old folks can get the ground floor. On the Mansions side we prefer Magnolia. It is closer to the bridge at the island. That said, we usually prefer to stay at FQ these days, as it is smaller, quieter, all the buildings have elevators and it has much better river views, which we like. We are always happy to make the most of wherever we end up, however, based on room availability/rates. Hope this helps. :)
MardiGroggy
Aka: Steve

"Laissez les bons temps rouler!"
Thorpy
Posts: 171
Joined: February 10th, 2013, 1:06 pm

Re: POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

Unread post by Thorpy »

We haven't been in all sections, but we go for magnolia terrace whenever we stay there. Lovely building, wander over the island past the pool to get to the food court. Makes for a great walk in a morning whenI get sent for drinks !
rksteel
Posts: 2
Joined: July 28th, 2016, 8:19 am

Re: POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

Unread post by rksteel »

Thanks for the responses! Aside from some offsite stays and one at the Poly, we have always stayed in the AB section, Probably getting a connecting room on our upcoming trip, so the option of staying in one of the mansions presented itself.

Family loves the POR, my DDs didn't want to stay at another resort for the next trip. So it is really a matter of staying with what you know or trying something new. Biggest concern was that the mansions may "feel" more crowded since its not as spread out as AB.

Thanks again.
User avatar
Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 2094
Joined: September 11th, 2008, 6:44 am
Contact:

Re: POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

Unread post by Admin »

Don't worry, the mansions feel a bit more "ordered" I guess - less of the overgrown vegetation feel and more manicured lawns - but still just as nice to stay in. I'm in one now as it happens, and it's lovely!

Andre
Image
- The Unofficial Visitor's Guide to the Port Orleans Resorts in Orlando, Florida -
Godalejrbud8
Posts: 20
Joined: February 27th, 2016, 12:51 pm

Re: POR-Alligator Bayou or Magnolia Bend?

Unread post by Godalejrbud8 »

My wife and I stayed in Acadia House this spring and enjoyed the change from ab. We had only stayed in ab previously, with the kids. This year we went by ourselves and felt it was a little more sophisticated! It was also less than 5 minutes to the lobby and bus stop.
Post Reply